Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Autumn light on a gray-brown stone home with slate gables, white shutters and a broad lawn.

In Chester County, the Price You Pay Can Become the School District's Appeal Evidence

November 5, 2026

In the Tredyffrin/Easttown School District, a written regulation tells the business manager to go through county sales records and list every taxable parcel that sold in the two fiscal years before the appeal deadline where the sale price runs at least 20% above the market value implied by the existing assessment. The district then narrows that list to parcels where a successful appeal would add more than $10,000 to its own first-year tax revenue and where the cost of pursuing the appeal still leaves a positive cost/benefit result. The regulation says parcels meeting these criteria "shall be selected for appeal."

Assessments and Appeals in Chester County

Chester County assessments represent 100% of a property's full market value as of the county's base year, which is decades old. Many homes, especially larger or heavily improved ones, carry assessments far below what they sell for today.

An appeal involves two numbers. First, the Chester County Board of Assessment Appeals sets a fair market value from the evidence submitted. Then the board applies the Common Level Ratio to that value to get the new assessment. The Pennsylvania State Tax Equalization Board certified Chester County's ratio at 30.6% on May 20, 2026, for use from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. The STEB certification says the ratio is for assessment appeals only.

The assessment is the base for every taxing body that bills the property. In Chester County that includes county government, 14 school districts and most of the 73 municipalities.

Court Decisions on District Appeals

On May 19, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court decided Downingtown Area School District v. Chester County Board of Assessment Appeals. The case concerned a district's monetary threshold for choosing which properties to appeal under the state's Uniformity Clause. In that case, Downingtown's consultant had identified fifteen properties that met the district's threshold. The district then added a recently sold apartment complex whose assessment was well below its stipulated fair market value. The Commonwealth Court had found the policy arbitrarily applied. The Supreme Court vacated that judgment and sent the case back for any remaining issues.

In the Upper Merion Area School District case in Montgomery County, the Commonwealth Court affirmed in March 2026 that the district violated the Uniformity Clause by deliberately excluding single-family homes and appealing only commercial and industrial properties.

Three Districts, Three Written Rules

Every district writes its own policy, and the wording matters. Here is how the three Chester County policies with published criteria compare:

District Policy How sales come into it The $10,000 test counts Filing language Latest date on the policy
Tredyffrin/Easttown Regulation 3295 Staff list sales from the prior two fiscal years with a 20%+ gap between sale price and assessment-implied value Revenue to the school district alone, first year, plus a positive cost/benefit result Qualifying parcels "shall be selected for appeal" Revised May 26, 2026
Downingtown Area Policy 605.1 The business manager "may review recent real estate transactions" Revenue to all taxing districts within the school district, combined Properties recommended when the bar is reasonably expected to be met Revised April 13, 2023
Kennett Consolidated Policy 627 The chief financial officer "may review recent real estate transactions" Revenue to all taxing districts within the school district, combined The board generally approves appeals before filing Reviewed April 13, 2026

T/E counts only its own revenue. Downingtown and Kennett count the combined increase across every taxing body in the school district. Downingtown's 2026-27 school rate is 33.0268 mills, adopted May 13, 2026.

Kennett's policy says the chief financial officer can authorize a filing ahead of a deadline, with the appeal presented to the board for ratification at its next business meeting.

The county notes that an annual appeal opens the property to revaluation, and the assessment can go down, go up or stay the same.

A Short FAQ

Do the Downingtown and Kennett policies mention recent sales? The Downingtown and Kennett policies describe reviewing recent transactions as one way to find under-assessed properties, and the Supreme Court case involved properties picked through a consultant's analysis as well as a recent sale.

What have courts said about district appeals? The Commonwealth Court's 2026 Upper Merion decision found that a policy deliberately excluding single-family homes violated the Uniformity Clause. In the Downingtown case, the Supreme Court vacated a judgment that the policy was arbitrarily applied.

Where does the 30.6% figure come from? STEB calculates it as the median ratio of assessment to sale price across valid 2025 Chester County sales, after trimming outliers. It is certified for use from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027.

This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Assessment appeals depend on facts specific to each property, so confirm your situation with a qualified tax attorney or accountant before acting on it.

Contact the Megan Van Arkel Team.

Work With Us

The Megan Van Arkel Team is dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. Contact them today to start your home-searching journey!